0 Members and 1 Guests are viewing this board.
- Garby
- Irregular
- 46 posts
- Reputation 24
-
Honourable
Dishonourable
- Loco Mofos, where we are crazy and like moms
Jul 25 2022 11:25 am
Hi Shadowing . . .
I know you have previously indicated a new battle system coming, but when? Here are details on a recent battle that makes absolutely no sense.
Attacker
0 Attack
0 Defense
20 Math
19 Physics
DS - 5685
Cr - 1282
BS - 1492
CS - 1
TR - 106
CV - 115419
eCV - 137,348
Defender
2 Attack
1 Defense
24 Math
28 Physics
DS - 15987
CR - 2260
BS - 1137
SB - 13
CS - 0
TR - 1000
CV - 171195
eCV - 330406
Outcome
Defender wins, but with complete loss of the fleet. Attacker had 0% to win, 1000 TRs killed additionally.
So, a player with a BONUS to defense, loses fleet at a ratio of 1.48? This makes absolutely no sense. Even taking the adjusted fleet sizes based on the effective CV, the BC says the losses should be:
DS - 30855
CR - 4362
BS - 541
I know these values don't make sense based on the above fleet sizes, but this is adjusting the fleets for the effective CV and then seeing how they lose fleet. It's complete loss of the DS and CR, but only a third of the BS are lost.
Additionally, it seems that in ATTACK, TR and CS are not killed unless the attacker losses the battle, but in defense, TR and CS are ALWAYS killed regardless if the battle is won or lost. TRs and CS should only be killed if the defender LOSES the battle. They are the last ships to be engaged and not sent into battle.
It wouldn't take running these battles through the WOPR in "War Games" to determine the only way to win war is to avoid it. Please let us know when the new battle system is coming into play.
Garby, Lord of the dance
- Slimhpie
- Irregular
- 4 posts
- Reputation 2
-
Honourable
Dishonourable
- I love 26horses Productions
Mar 28 2024 6:38 am
We are almost 2 years later and there are still battle issues. Yesterday I had some friendly fire incoming of 2 times 50 ds. The first fleet landed and I gained my kill points, leaving me a good enoug SB and fleet to catch up the seccond fleet.
Later I checked the battle details and I found that it says Defeat, while the fight was 50 attacking DS and 34DS and SB11 defending (so the news was correct).
An hour later another 50DS landed and there the News says DEFEAT, but the battle report shows me as defender winning where all my 34 DS did survive. But the planet was sieged with no ships and when I reinforced the planet stayed sieged until I relaunched my own fleet of the planet. Normaly the SB9 and 34DS on the planet should be enough for sure....
26horses Production